Well, he really did it.
A couple of weeks into the new and final season of Curb Your Enthusiasm, the signs were almost blatantly clear that Larry David was not going to pass up the opportunity to do the funniest thing ever and use the series finale of Curb as a meta-commentary on the last time he was tasked with ending a long-running beloved comedy series, when it didnât go so well.
The last episode of Curb leans right into the Seinfeld callbacks from the rip, starting with its title, âNo Lessons Learnedââa reference to the âno hugging, no learningâ mantra David and co-creator Jerry Seinfeld ran their sitcom under, a rebuke to the pat writing style of network television, where characters would end an episode learning from their mistakes. Instead, by the end of Seinfeldâs nine-season run, Jerry, George, Elaine and Kramer had arguably hardened into full-on sociopaths with behavior fit to put them on trial forâand TV Larry isnât much better.
But clearly real-Larryâdespite standing ten toes down on his decisions for the Seinfeld finale in generalâhas been thinking about why it didnât connect, and how some critics back in 1998 could have found it âbloated and off-key.â Rewatching âThe Finale,â it really is a glorified clip show, with past one-off characters performing encores that essentially just yell âremember when?â at the audience. But in â98 at least clip shows were the norm, before home video was really a thing. In 2024, weâve all rewatched Curb dozens of times, so the bar is a little bit higher for cameos that will really get a rise out of the audience. David tries his best, reaching way back for characters you wouldnât rank high on the appearance list from classic episodes like âThe Ski Lift,â or surprises like the little girl from âThe Dollâ (arguably the showâs best episode) all grown up.
Ultimately though, those feel about as shrug-worthy as they did on SeinfeldâIâd rather just run âThe Dollâ back than see a clip from the episodeâs punchline. But Larryâs new finale-redux succeeds where the last one faltered by mixing up the pomp and circumstance of the episodeâs plot with just really good, classic Curb energy, injecting in some of the best bits heâs written all season. We get one last Eye-to-Eye, this time with the legend Allison Janney, over whether her character really tried to commit suicide. Thereâs one last Larry and Susie caper, one of those rare moments when they put aside their mortal disdain for each other for the benefit of the team, where in an echo of âThe Ski Liftâ (when Susie masquerades as Larry’s wife during a weekend with an Orthodox Jewish family that they need a favor from), Susie pretends to be Larryâs paraplegic new girlfriend to garner some sympathy points for the jury. One last absurd Leon-ism, this time about detachable dicks. And man, Jerry Seinfeld himself walking into Larryâs hotel lobby as a show of emotional support could have reeked of stunt-castingâ¦until they start riffing on something completely unrelated and totally absurd and you remember how much of a joy it is to just watch these two banter.
Jerry gets to save the day and stop Larry from repeating history. Just as Larry sits in a cell, facing one year in prison upon being found guiltyâand bemoaning the Pants Tent, in a callback to the showâs pilot, much like Jerry and Georgeâs final dialogue echoed the Seinfeld pilotâJerry rushes in with the news that since he caught a juror not observing the sequester the night before the verdict. The judge has declared a mistrial, and Larry gets to walk free. On their way out, Larry has a lightbulb moment: âThis is how we shouldâve ended [Seinfeld],â with Jerry noting that âno one wants to seeâ their comedy protagonist in jail.
But it wouldnât be true to the spirit of Curb if things ended there. The actual last scene is the gangâLarry, Leon, Jeff, Susie, Cheryl, Ted Danson, and Jerryâhaving one last argument over etiquette, this time across the first class cabin of their plane as Susie raises her window blinding everything else. How fitting that the last, clear line of dialog of Curb Your Enthusiasm is Susie Greene getting one last dig in: âGo back to jail, Larry.â No hugging, no learning.